There's a good
article over at
pandagon, taking apart some B.S. post about how Thanksgiving isn't "for" vegetarians.* The only addendum I'd like to put to that is a look at this weird urban legend they mention, that soy products give you man boobs. The idea is that it can mimic estrogen, so it can increase female sexual characteristics, such as breasts. This can be easily proven by the huge racks we see on men in Asia. Um....
OK, so the science seems to be scant to nonexistent that any, you know, human amount of intake of soy products will have a noticeable effect on people, but it still persists as an oft-mentioned warning. Far, far more than the well demonstrated and documented effects of plastics, some of which most certainly do mimic estrogen and in far greater amounts, and growth hormones in cow's milk (here's a fun fact: women who drink non-organic, regular ol' cow's milk are
twice as likely to have twins than women who drink organic cow's milk). So why does this get far more currency than those other, much more solidly supported dangers? There are two reasons, and looking at them is a fairly interesting window into culture, memes, and racist assholes.
One of the reasons that it continues, the less interesting one, is that this danger is a problem for only a small group of people, and almost never the person repeating it. One might think that we would pay the most attention to dangers inherent in activities we ourselves do, since that would make us safer, but the reality is far different. If you hear that a thing you do, X, is unhealthy or dangerous, yet you strongly want to continue doing it, you feel cognitive dissonance. This leads to not remembering/not thinking about the warning. If on the other hand you hear that a thing you don't do, Y, is unhealthy or bad in some way, you feel good about yourself and remember it quite well; especially when you see someone else doing that thing which you are too virtuous to do.
The other, more interesting reason this urban legend continues, and urban legends in general can continue, is that it is compatible with already-held unexamined beliefs. (Feel Free To Skip)When a meme reinforces a pre-existing complex of other memes, it both strengthens that complex and can attach itself to it. This is especially true when the complex is itself not critically examined, either because one of the memes in it is not to examine (faith/taboo) or because it is so fully integrated into someone's overall doxastic system that altering it would be too much epistemological work. (/Feel Free To Skip)That's another way of saying that when something sounds plausible based on other things you know, you'll believe it, especially if it makes you feel good about yourself.
In this particular case, there are two long-held, unexamined bigotries at work here. The first is that Asian men are effeminate, unlike us burly strong white guys (though we lose out to the animalistic dark-skinned guys.) The other is that
eating meat is connected to masculinity
>. These both strongly support and are supported by the idea that eating tofu and drinking soy milk puts lady hormones in your manly body. When ideas as deep-seated as these are the ones giving support, it's an easy guess that the resultant belief will itself not be very well-examined. Hence the persistence of this idea despite little to no evidence of any kind.
If all this implicit subtext is hard for you to believe, well, actually my first suggestion is take some feminist theory classes, but my
second suggestion is to read this article, where the subtext is turned into straight-up, good-old-fashioned explicit text:
Soy is making kids "gay"**
*As we all know, it's "for" celebrating the massacre of Native Americans. I don't mean that symbolically. It
actually was declared a holiday in Massachusetts to celebrate a massacre of Native American women and children.
**I love how he puts "gay" in quotes. Is this so we know he doesn't mean happy? Or that he reeeeeeally wants to say fag, but feels that this would detract from the sober scientific tone of his piece?
Read the Rest